Received an ADA Demand Letter? Here Is What to Do First
An ADA demand letter about your website is a serious legal document, but it is not a lawsuit — and how you respond in the first 30 days will significantly shape your outcome. These letters, typically from plaintiff law firms alleging WCAG accessibility violations, arrive with urgent language and short response windows by design. Before you panic, ignore it, or rush to call your general business attorney, understand what you are actually dealing with.
What an ADA Demand Letter Contains
- Identification of the plaintiff and their claimed disability
- Description of the specific accessibility barriers they allegedly encountered
- Citation to ADA Title III and applicable court decisions
- A demand for monetary settlement, site remediation, or both
- A response deadline, typically 14 to 30 days
- Threat to file a federal complaint if demands are not met
Typical Timeline After Receiving a Demand Letter
Days 1–5: Engage an ADA Compliance Attorney
Retain an attorney with specific ADA Title III experience within the first five days. General business counsel without ADA website experience may give advice that inadvertently weakens your position.
Days 5–14: Commission an Accessibility Audit
Simultaneously commission an independent WCAG 2.1 AA audit. This verifies whether alleged barriers exist and generates documentation of your good-faith compliance effort for negotiations.
Days 14–60: Negotiate and Remediate
Documented remediation progress — showing you have fixed or are actively fixing identified barriers — is typically the single most effective tool for reducing settlement demands.
When to Settle vs. When to Fight
- Settle when: barriers genuinely exist and remediation plus settlement is less than full litigation
- Settle when: plaintiff's firm has a consistent litigation record in your jurisdiction
- Fight when: standing arguments are strong (no physical location nexus in circuits requiring it)
- Fight when: barriers alleged do not actually exist on your site
- Fight when: plaintiff has filed 50+ similar cases and courts in your circuit scrutinize serial filers
How BuildWithAccess Supports Businesses Facing Demand Letters
BuildWithAccess offers expedited audit service for demand letter timelines — a full WCAG 2.1 AA audit report within 5 to 7 business days, with a prioritized remediation plan and compliance documentation formatted for legal proceedings. We work alongside your ADA attorney to provide the technical foundation for negotiating from a position of strength.
Sarah Mitchell
Senior Accessibility Consultant
A certified accessibility consultant at BuildWithAccess helping organizations achieve WCAG compliance and build more inclusive digital experiences.
Need help making your site accessible?
We offer free consultations to assess your current accessibility posture and recommend a path forward.
Get a Free Consultation